Clubfree
Head-to-head

FX Replay vs Forex Tester

Two tools, the same criteria: price, features, ease of use and prop firm compatibility (2026).

By Kyro, founder · Checked on

Our pick

FX Replay

9.1/10

Market replay with a prop firm simulator

4 / 4 criteria won out of 5Read review
VS
Challenger

Forex Tester

8.4/10

The historical backtesting software

0 / 4 criteria won out of 5Read review
Head-to-head verdict · FX Replay

FX Replay wins with its prop firm simulator, low price and modern interface. Forex Tester keeps the edge with its lifetime licence and tick data.

Full comparison

FX ReplayForex Tester
Score9.1/108.4/10
From$15/mo$199/yr
TrialFree plan30-day refund
MarketsForex, Futures, Crypto, StocksForex, Crypto, Stocks
CompatibilityWebWeb, Windows
Price9.08.6
Features8.88.6
Ease of use9.28.0
Prop firm compatibility9.48.2

Choose FX Replay if you…

  • Traders preparing a challenge
  • Those testing a strategy by hand

Choose Forex Tester if you…

  • Forex traders who backtest a lot

Pricing and plans

FX Replay

Limited free plan. Intermediate $15/mo ($180/yr), Pro $35/mo ($350/yr) with unlimited sessions, futures and stock data, second-level data.

Forex Tester

Forex Tester Online from about $199/yr (frequent promotions), 30-day money-back guarantee. The desktop version is available as a lifetime licence.

Strengths and weaknesses

FX Replay strengths

  • Prop firm simulator
  • Low price
  • Free plan to try it

FX Replay weaknesses

  • Futures data on Pro only
  • Manual backtesting only

Forex Tester strengths

  • Accurate tick data
  • Lifetime desktop licence
  • 30-day refund

Forex Tester weaknesses

  • Mostly forex
  • Older interface than FX Replay

FAQ: FX Replay or Forex Tester?

FX Replay or Forex Tester: which is cheaper?

FX Replay has the lowest entry price ($15/mo), versus $199/yr for Forex Tester. Public prices shown by the vendors, excluding promotions.

Do FX Replay and Forex Tester have a free trial?

FX Replay: Free plan. Forex Tester: 30-day refund.

Which one suits a prop firm trader best?

On prop firm compatibility, FX Replay scores 9.4/10 versus 8.2/10 for Forex Tester.

Which devices do FX Replay and Forex Tester run on?

FX Replay: Web. Forex Tester: Web, Windows.

Should you choose FX Replay or Forex Tester?

FX Replay wins with its prop firm simulator, low price and modern interface. Forex Tester keeps the edge with its lifetime licence and tick data.